My debtor company suddenly has a new nominee director — can I still get my money?
New director, new address, nobody reachable: this is usually a 'company burial' — and it is precisely then that people become personally liable. I show you whom you can pursue, within which deadlines, and in what order.
You hold a judgment or an undisputed invoice against a limited company (GmbH) — and all of a sudden the commercial register shows a name nobody has heard of. The former director has been removed, the shares have been sold, the registered business address sits somewhere without so much as a nameplate, and post comes back undelivered. This is neither coincidence nor a reason to write the debt off: it is precisely this pattern that opens the door to people who, until now, were sheltered behind the limitation of liability.
In short
Swapping in a nominee does not deprive you of your debtor — as a rule it enlarges the group of people who are personally liable to you with their private assets. If the switch bears the hallmarks of a “company burial” (Firmenbestattung), the underlying resolutions and transfers may be void — in which case the old director never actually left office and remains both under a duty to file and personally liable. On top of that come claims against the nominee himself, against the shareholders, and against the people pulling the strings, because a breach of the duty to file for insolvency under § 15a InsO gives rise to damages under § 823 Abs. 2 BGB. The lever for all of this is almost always your own insolvency petition — not the next round of enforcement.
How I help you
- I examine the commercial register, the official announcements and the accounts, and I place the matter: an ordinary change of director, or a burial pattern.
- I establish whether the removal of the director and the transfer of the shares were effective — this determines whom you can pursue.
- I take the statement of assets (Vermögensauskunft) from the new director and, with it, obtain the information you need for everything that follows.
- I file the creditor’s insolvency petition and reclaim the costs advance from the person who, in breach of duty, failed to file.
- I calculate the loss for which you are personally entitled to compensation and pursue it against the individuals involved, both out of court and in litigation.
Why the switch improves your legal position
In the typical burial pattern several steps happen in quick succession: the shares pass for a token price to a buyer with no means of his own, the existing director is removed, an impecunious third party or someone living abroad is appointed, the registered office and company name are changed, and the records vanish. In commercial terms this is not a takeover at all — it is the removal of a body that was under a duty to file.
A transaction that offends against public policy is void under § 138 Abs. 1 BGB. If the share transfer serves solely to make the company untraceable to the detriment of its creditors, it may for that reason be ineffective; the same applies, under the rules governing shareholder resolutions, to the resolution removing and appointing a director where its very content is aimed at that purpose. The consequence is decisive for you: the old director then never effectively left office. The duty under § 15a Abs. 1 InsO and the liability for payments under § 15b InsO continue to rest on him — regardless of what the register says, because the filing under § 39 Abs. 1 GmbHG merely publicises the change, it does not bring it about.
For the purposes of liability it is, in any event, not the state of the register that counts but who actually runs the business. Anyone who continues to make the decisions while someone else formally signs is treated as the director.
Who is personally liable to you — and how you reach those claims
Keep two types of claim apart, or you will litigate past your goal.
Your own claims belong directly to you. § 15a InsO is a statute intended to protect creditors; anyone who breaches the duty to file is therefore liable to you under § 823 Abs. 2 BGB. How much depends on timing: if you were already a creditor before the company became insolvent, you are generally compensated for the disadvantage that the available assets shrank through the delay. If you only came on board afterwards, the claim is for the loss you suffered by supplying or paying at all. Anyone who intentionally inflicts harm in a manner contrary to public policy is additionally liable under § 826 BGB — which typically catches the organisers of the burial and the buyer. Instigators and accessories are placed on the same footing as joint tortfeasors under § 830 Abs. 2 BGB, and where several people are responsible they are liable as joint and several debtors under § 840 Abs. 1 BGB. You can therefore pick whichever of them is worth pursuing.
The company’s claims do not belong to you, but they are often the larger figure: the restitution of all payments made after the onset of insolvency or over-indebtedness under § 15b Abs. 1 and 4 InsO, the liability for breaches of duty under § 43 Abs. 2 GmbHG, and the liability of shareholders under § 6 Abs. 5 GmbHG where they intentionally or with gross negligence hand the management to someone who cannot lawfully be a director at all under § 6 Abs. 2 GmbHG — for instance because of a conviction for delaying an insolvency filing, which disqualifies for five years. You reach these claims in one of two ways: you have them attached and transferred to you as a claim of the company against its director, or an insolvency administrator collects them in. That is why the petition is worthwhile.
The sequence, in this order
First, information. If an enforcement attempt fails or the director refuses a search of the premises, the statement of assets can be taken straight away under § 807 ZPO. For a GmbH it is the director who gives it, and under § 802c Abs. 1 und 2 ZPO he must also state the company name, the register sheet and the registered office, together with transactions for value to connected persons over the last two years and gratuitous dispositions over the last four years. That is exactly where it shows where the assets went.
Second, service. If nobody can be reached, service runs publicly under § 185 Nr. 2 ZPO where it cannot be effected at the registered business address, on a registered person authorised to receive it, or at any further domestic address known without the need for investigation. If there is no director at all, the shareholders represent the company for the purpose of receiving service under § 35 Abs. 1 Satz 2 GmbHG. So your proceedings keep moving.
Third, the insolvency petition. It is admissible under § 14 Abs. 1 InsO where you have a legal interest and establish, to the standard of prima facie proof, both the claim and a ground for opening proceedings — inability to pay under § 17 Abs. 2 InsO or over-indebtedness under § 19 Abs. 2 InsO. The fruitless enforcement attempt and the failure to give the statement of assets are usable material for this. If the assets are insufficient to cover the costs of the proceedings, the petition is dismissed under § 26 Abs. 1 InsO unless an advance is paid. And here is the lever: whoever pays the advance may claim reimbursement under § 26 Abs. 3 InsO from any person who, in breach of duty and culpably, failed to file — and it is that person who bears the burden of proving that he did not act in breach of duty. Under § 26 Abs. 4 InsO the advance can even be demanded from him directly.
Fourth, time. The duty to file existed without culpable delay, and at the latest within three weeks of the onset of inability to pay and six weeks of the onset of over-indebtedness (§ 15a Abs. 1 InsO). Where the company is left without a director, the duty also falls under § 15a Abs. 3 InsO on every shareholder who had knowledge. Claims under § 15b InsO are time-barred after five years (§ 15b Abs. 7 InsO), as are those under § 43 GmbHG (§ 43 Abs. 4 GmbHG); your own claims in tort are time-barred under the general rules, usually after three years running from the end of the year in which you learnt of the loss and of the person liable. An insolvency administrator can challenge dispositions of assets going back up to ten years under § 133 InsO, and four years where security or satisfaction was granted.
A typical case
A trades business holds a judgment for a construction payment claim from the previous year. Two weeks after the first enforcement attempt, a new director is entered in the register, the address changes, and the annual accounts have been missing for two years. The old director points to his successor, who cannot be reached. We take the statement of assets; it is not given, and the application for entry in the register of debtors under § 882b ZPO proceeds. In parallel we file the insolvency petition and give notice that we will recover the costs advance from the old director under § 26 Abs. 3 InsO. His payments over the last few months show that the company had long been unable to pay. In the end it is settled not by the GmbH but by him.
Common mistakes
- Continuing to enforce when it is clear the shell is empty: every further round of enforcement costs money and yields no more information.
- Treating the entry in the commercial register as the legal position. Whether the old director is still in office turns on whether the resolution is effective, not on the entry.
- Shying away from the insolvency petition because the proceedings will probably be dismissed for want of assets. The dismissal is not a failure — it documents that the company was insolvent and triggers the duties of reimbursement and advance.
- Treating the nominee as the only opponent. The shareholders, the buyer and the advisers who organised this are the ones of interest.
- Waiting too long. Dispositions can only be clawed back within the challenge periods, and witnesses and records go cold with every passing month.
Frequently asked questions
Is the new nominee director liable at all if he never decided anything?
Yes. The duty to file under § 15a Abs. 1 InsO rests personally on every member of the body representing the company, and ignorance about one’s own business is no excuse. Anyone who accepts the office and does nothing is liable under § 823 Abs. 2 BGB; breaching the duty is a criminal offence under § 15a Abs. 4 InsO, punishable by imprisonment of up to three years or a fine, and where committed negligently, under § 15a Abs. 5 InsO, by up to one year. The fact that there is little to be had from him changes none of this — it is merely a reason to bring in the others involved.
Can I still pursue the old director even though he has been removed?
Often, yes. If the removal is part of a process whose sole purpose is to disadvantage creditors, it may be ineffective, in which case his duty continued without interruption. Quite apart from that, he is liable for everything that happened during his time in office after the onset of insolvency, and in particular for payments under § 15b Abs. 1 und 4 InsO.
Is an insolvency petition worthwhile if there is nothing there anyway?
In this situation, usually yes — though not for the sake of the dividend. The petition compels a judicial examination, leads under § 26 Abs. 1 InsO to dismissal for want of assets together with entry in the register of debtors, and, through § 26 Abs. 3 und 4 InsO, opens direct access to the person who failed to file. If proceedings are opened, the administrator can challenge dispositions of assets under § 133 InsO.
How do I prove the GmbH was already insolvent before the switch?
Under § 14 Abs. 1 InsO the petition only requires prima facie proof, not full proof. Useful material includes the fruitless enforcement attempt, the refused or unprovided statement of assets, missing annual accounts, broken promises to pay by instalments, and information from other creditors. In the liability proceedings, the director’s duty to give information and — once proceedings are opened — the accounts supply the rest.
What will this cost me?
What I do for you, and what it costs, I discuss with you at the initial consultation before anything is set in motion. The fees are governed by the RVG or by an agreement; if you have legal expenses insurance, we clarify cover in advance. I will also work through with you, beforehand, the advance-payment risks of the insolvency petition against the reimbursement claims under § 26 Abs. 3 und 4 InsO.
Your next step
When a new name appears in the register and the post comes back, time is running against you: every month shortens the challenge periods and lets the trail go cold. Send me the judgment or the invoice, the current register extract and the last returned post — with that I can usually tell you within a few days whether the switch was effective, who is personally liable, and whether the insolvency petition makes sense for you. You will find the other questions I handle in civil law set out in the overview. I work throughout Germany; I hold the initial consultation by video or telephone, and everything you tell me in it is covered by my duty of confidentiality.
This article provides general information and is no substitute for an examination of your individual case.
This article provides general information and is no substitute for legal advice in an individual case. Last updated: 2026-11-20.

Christian Czirnich, Rechtsanwalt (attorney at law), Kirchseeon near Munich
Tell me who owes you what and what changed at the company – I will look into it.
I read every message myself and usually reply on the next working day. What you write to me is covered by legal professional privilege from the first word, even if no engagement comes about. The initial assessment is free of charge.
Your message has arrived. I will usually reply on the next working day. If it is urgent: 08091 617 7777