A private patient won't pay the bill — why do I now have to go to the Regional Court?
Since 1 January 2026, disputes arising from medical treatment fall to the Regional Courts (Landgerichte) — regardless of the amount in dispute. What that means for your outstanding private invoice, which deadlines are running, and how to enforce your fee.
You carried out the treatment, billed under the GOÄ or GOZ, sent two reminders — and the private patient still hasn’t paid. Now you want to enforce the claim through the courts, and you’re told: not the Local Court (Amtsgericht) but the Regional Court (Landgericht), even for €420. That isn’t a mistake. Since the start of 2026, it’s simply the law.
In brief
Disputes arising from medical treatment fall to the exclusive jurisdiction of the Regional Courts, regardless of the amount in dispute (§ 71 Abs. 2 Nr. 9 GVG). The rule applies to proceedings that become pending on or after 1 January 2026; older proceedings stay where they are (§ 44 EGGVG). On the broad wording, a fee claim arising from the treatment will generally fall within it — however small the sum. Before the Regional Court you must be represented by a lawyer (§ 78 Abs. 1 ZPO); you cannot bring the claim yourself.
How I can help
- Checking whether your invoice is actually due for payment — and putting it right before any costs arise
- A formal out-of-court demand with the consequences of default, instead of a toothless third reminder
- Deciding between the dunning procedure (Mahnverfahren) and going straight to a claim, with the correct court named
- Representing you in the fee claim before the Regional Court, even where the patient alleges a treatment error
- Obtaining the judgment, enforcement, and protecting the claim against limitation before the year end
Why the Regional Court — and what changes for you
The Local Court’s value threshold is €10,000 (§ 23 Nr. 1 GVG), but it applies only where the matter has not been assigned to the Regional Courts irrespective of value. That is precisely what has now happened for medical treatment matters. The jurisdiction is exclusive: you cannot opt out of it, and you cannot shift it by agreement with the patient. At the Regional Court the matter goes to a chamber set up for this subject area (§ 72a Abs. 1 Nr. 3 GVG), and on appeal to a corresponding senate of the Higher Regional Court (§ 119a Abs. 1 Nr. 3 GVG).
In practice, three things follow:
- Mandatory legal representation. What you used to be able to handle yourself as the practice owner is no longer possible. Even a debt-collection service may represent you in the dunning procedure only up to the point the matter passes to the trial court (§ 79 Abs. 2 Satz 2 Nr. 4 ZPO) — once it reaches the Regional Court, that’s the end of it.
- A higher value in dispute per instance, and higher fees. In the end these costs are usually borne by the losing party; but until then they have to be advanced.
- Claims filed at the wrong court cost time. If you file at the Local Court, the matter is referred to the Regional Court on application (§ 281 ZPO). That can easily mean two months lost, plus the extra costs.
On my assessment, a patient’s dispute with their private health insurer over reimbursement is not caught — that is a dispute arising from the insurance contract, not from medical treatment. Exactly where the boundaries of this new concept run in borderline cases has not yet been fully worked through.
Before you sue: is the invoice even due?
This is where fee claims most often come unstuck. The fee only becomes due once the person liable to pay has been issued with an invoice that complies with the fee schedule (§ 12 Abs. 1 GOÄ, § 10 Abs. 1 GOZ). If a mandatory particular is missing, nothing is due — no default, no interest, and any claim has been brought too early.
What the invoice must contain (§ 12 Abs. 2 GOÄ, § 10 Abs. 2 GOZ, here reduced to the usual points of contention):
- the date each service was provided
- the number and description of each individual service, including any minimum duration stated in the service description
- the relevant amount and the multiplier (Steigerungssatz)
- the nature and amount of disbursements; in dentistry, additionally material and laboratory details, and for commissioned dental-technical work the laboratory invoice attached
Where a fee exceeds the 2.3 multiplier, that must be justified in writing, in terms specific to the individual service, in a way that is intelligible and can be followed (§ 12 Abs. 3 GOÄ, § 10 Abs. 3 GOZ). A boilerplate phrase such as “increased time required” under every line item will not do. Within the applicable range, a fee may as a rule be set only between the single and the 2.3 multiplier; beyond that only where particular features of difficulty, time required or the circumstances of performance justify it (§ 5 Abs. 2 GOÄ).
If you are relying on a fee agreement, I check it in the same places patients attack it: an individually negotiated arrangement in the particular case, written form, concluded before the service, stating the number, description, multiplier and amount, the note that reimbursement may be incomplete — and no further declarations in the document (§ 2 GOÄ, § 2 GOZ). On top of that comes the cost information in text form before treatment begins, where you knew, or had sufficient indications, that a third party would not cover the costs in full (§ 630c Abs. 3 BGB).
The good news: a defective invoice can usually be put right. With a properly drawn-up new invoice, the claim falls due — but default then only runs from that point.
Deadlines and interest — with the sums worked through
The fee claim becomes time-barred after three years (§ 195 BGB). The period begins at the end of the year in which the claim arose and you knew of the circumstances giving rise to it and the identity of the debtor (§ 199 Abs. 1 BGB). A worked example: a compliant invoice in May 2026, due in 2026, the period beginning on 31 December 2026 and ending on 31 December 2029. If the invoice is only drawn up correctly later, the due date shifts — but you should not build your timing around that.
Limitation is suspended by bringing a claim (§ 204 Abs. 1 Nr. 1 BGB) or by service of the dunning order (Mahnbescheid) (§ 204 Abs. 1 Nr. 3 BGB). What counts is service, not receipt by the court. Anyone filing on 22 December is trusting the court to manage it in time.
Default arises through a reminder after the due date (§ 286 Abs. 1 BGB), and for consumers at the latest 30 days after the claim falls due and the invoice is received — but only if you specifically drew attention to that consequence in the invoice (§ 286 Abs. 3 BGB). Interest on default against a patient as a consumer is five percentage points above the base rate (§ 288 Abs. 1 BGB); the nine percentage points under § 288 Abs. 2 BGB apply only where no consumer is involved.
How I go about it
- Checking the invoice, the fee agreement, the treatment and cost plan, and the records. Where necessary, the compliant new invoice first — otherwise we are suing on a claim that isn’t due.
- A demand for payment with a deadline, the consequences of default, and interest. The patient often pays at this stage, recognising that the claim stands up.
- Setting the course: if the patient stays silent or only denies in general terms, the dunning procedure is the quicker route. It stays with the Local Courts (§ 689 Abs. 1 ZPO); the competent dunning court is the one at your general place of jurisdiction — and that applies expressly even where a different exclusive jurisdiction governs the dispute itself (§ 689 Abs. 2 ZPO). The application must name the trial court (§ 690 Abs. 1 Nr. 5 ZPO), and that is now the Regional Court. If the patient objects, the matter is passed there of the court’s own motion (§ 696 Abs. 1 ZPO); where it is passed on promptly, it is treated as having become pending already on service of the dunning order (§ 696 Abs. 3 ZPO).
- If the patient raises substantiated objections or alleges a treatment error, I bring the claim directly before the Regional Court rather than taking a detour through the dunning procedure.
- After the judgment: enforcement. Even following an objection to an enforcement order (Vollstreckungsbescheid), the matter goes to the Regional Court (§ 700 Abs. 3 ZPO).
A typical case
A dental practice has provided an implant restoration; €2,800 remains outstanding. The patient does not respond to three reminders. The practice files its own application for a dunning order and names the Local Court in it as the trial court. The patient objects and, for the first time, challenges the invoice: multipliers above 2.3 without a supporting justification, the laboratory invoice never attached. The matter is passed on, then referred to the Regional Court, where the practice needs a lawyer in any event — four months have gone by, and the basic question is still the same as at the outset: the claim was never due. The clean route would have been to correct the invoice, re-issue it, put the patient in default, and only then name the Regional Court as the trial court.
Common mistakes
- Filing a claim or dunning order without having measured the invoice against the GOÄ or GOZ
- Justifying the multipliers with a standard phrase rather than service by service
- Naming the Local Court as the trial court in the dunning application — with a hand-over, a referral and lost time as the result
- Relying on a fee agreement that was only signed during or after the treatment
- An invoice without the note that triggers the 30-day default consequence against consumers
- Year-end claims that rely on filing rather than on service
- Treating the patient’s allegation of a treatment error as a matter for negotiation, although it changes the whole proceedings
Frequently asked questions
Does the Regional Court’s jurisdiction really apply even at €300?
Yes. § 71 Abs. 2 Nr. 9 GVG establishes the jurisdiction expressly, regardless of the amount in dispute. There is no lower threshold. For small sums, then, the first question is a commercial one — whether the proceedings are worth it, and whether the patient is able to pay at all.
Do I already need a lawyer just for the dunning order?
No. The dunning procedure continues before the Local Courts, where there is no requirement of legal representation. But if the patient objects, or objects to an enforcement order, the matter goes to the Regional Court — and from there on you must be legally represented.
My case has been before the Local Court since 2025. Does it now have to go to the Regional Court?
No. The new provisions of § 71 Abs. 2 GVG do not apply to proceedings that became pending before 1 January 2026 (§ 44 EGGVG). Your existing case stays with the Local Court, even if it still has years to run.
The patient is now alleging a treatment error. What does that mean for my fee claim?
The objection becomes part of the proceedings, and an expert report may be required. That lengthens the matter and increases the costs risk on both sides. All the more reason for your documentation and your patient information to be robust before you pursue the claim through the courts — because then both will be examined.
What will enforcement cost me?
The lawyer’s fees are set by the RVG and thus by the size of the claim; court fees come on top. What arises in your case I will discuss openly in the initial consultation, including the question of whether legal expenses insurance will step in. Where the patient is in default, the costs of pursuing the claim are as a rule part of the loss they have to make good.
Your next step
When a private invoice is outstanding, success is decided before the first pleading: at the invoice, at the fee agreement, at the question of whether the claim fell due and default arose at all. Send me the invoice, the reminders, the fee agreement and — if there is one — the patient’s response. I’ll tell you whether the claim stands up, which route is the quickest, and what it will cost, before any money goes into proceedings. This is especially urgent for claims from 2023, where limitation may loom at the year end. You’ll find further articles on fee and contract disputes under Civil law. Advice is available nationwide, by video or telephone.
This article provides general information and is no substitute for an examination of your individual case.
This article provides general information and is no substitute for legal advice in an individual case. Last updated: 2026-11-16.

Christian Czirnich, Rechtsanwalt (attorney at law), Kirchseeon near Munich
Tell me what you billed and when you sent reminders – I will take a look.
I read every message myself and usually reply on the next working day. What you write to me is covered by legal professional privilege from the first word, even if no engagement comes about. The initial assessment is free of charge.
Your message has arrived. I will usually reply on the next working day. If it is urgent: 08091 617 7777