Divorce With a House: Which Value Counts — and What Can Be Deducted From It?
For the equalisation of accrued gains, what matters is the market value of the house on a single day: the day the divorce petition was served. Which deductions are recognised, which are not, and how the figure is worked out step by step.
You are separating, and the house is the biggest single item in the sum. Your idea of what it is worth and your spouse’s are a long way apart, and both sides have a case to make. Yet the figure that ultimately feeds into the equalisation of accrued gains can be pinned down precisely — more precisely than most kitchen-table negotiations manage.
In short
What counts is the market value of the house on one single day: the day the divorce petition was served on the other spouse (§ 1384 BGB). Not the purchase price, not the date of separation, not today’s market price. From that value you deduct the loans still outstanding on that day, to the extent they fall on the owner, and — if a sale would have been taxable — the income tax that would have arisen. You do not deduct wish-list renovations, the estate agent’s commission on a sale that is only imagined, or the cost of moving out.
How I can help you
- Establish and document the valuation date — the date of service is often not what the other side claims.
- Enforce disclosure of, and documentary proof of, the assets, through the court if necessary (§ 1379 BGB).
- Organise the valuation: demand an expert report, challenge one that has been put forward, scrutinise the valuation approach.
- Work through the deductions: the outstanding loan, co-ownership shares, latent tax.
- Index the initial assets where the house comes from pre-marital ownership, inheritance or gift.
- Negotiate a solution: taking the house on against a balancing payment, payment by instalments, a notarised agreement.
- Keep to the deadlines — the consolidation deadline in the divorce proceedings and the limitation period for the equalisation claim.
- Pursue, or fend off, a partition sale by auction.
The valuation date: one day, not a period
For the final assets, the point in time is in principle the end of the matrimonial property regime. In a divorce that moment is brought forward: what counts is the day the divorce petition becomes pending, that is, the day it is served on the other spouse (§ 1384 BGB). This has two consequences that move a great deal of money in practice.
First: increases in value after that day no longer belong in the calculation — not even if the proceedings run for another two years and the market rises in the meantime. Conversely, the owner alone bears any fall in value after the valuation date. Anyone who knows this can choose the moment of filing deliberately.
Second: the date of separation is not the valuation date. It has a different significance of its own. Under § 1379 Abs. 2 BGB you can demand disclosure of the assets as at the date of separation, and § 1375 Abs. 2 Satz 1 BGB adds back, under certain conditions, reductions in assets that occurred after the property regime began — that is, at any point during the whole of the marriage: gratuitous dispositions not made out of a moral duty, dissipation, or acts intended to disadvantage the other spouse. The boundary is drawn by § 1375 Abs. 3 BGB: if the reduction lies at least ten years before the end of the property regime, or if the other spouse consented, it is left out of account. Anyone who fails to obtain the disclosure as at separation loses the comparative figure for that date, and with it the easing of the burden of proof under § 1375 Abs. 2 Satz 2 BGB.
The value itself is the market value, that is, the price that could have been obtained on the open market on the valuation date. Not the purchase price back then, not the fire-insurance value, not the standard land value on its own, and not the sum of the building costs poured in. For an agricultural or forestry business, the earnings value may, under the conditions of § 1376 Abs. 4 BGB, take the place of the market value — but that is a narrowly drawn exception and does not concern an ordinary dwelling house.
What may be deducted — and what may not
The final assets are the assets after deduction of liabilities (§ 1375 Abs. 1 BGB). For the house that means three steps of inquiry.
First, the loans. What is deducted is the balance outstanding on the valuation date, not the original loan amount. The decisive question is who the debt falls on: if both spouses are borrowers, the liability is as a rule attributed to each of them by half, even if only one of them owns the property. Anyone who sets the whole debt against themselves and the whole value against the other systematically makes themselves out to be poorer or richer than they are.
Second, latent tax. The market value is a notional sale price. If that sale would have been taxable on the valuation date, then the value could never have been realised in full by the owner; the tax burden therefore, as a rule, reduces the value to be applied. For a dwelling house this turns on § 23 EStG: if more than ten years lie between acquisition and disposal, the gain is not taxable in any event — in which case there is nothing to deduct. The same applies where the house was used as the owner’s own home throughout the period, or in the year of disposal and the two preceding years. In practice, then, the deduction becomes relevant mainly for let properties within the ten-year period. It is not automatic: the deduction has to be raised and the amount worked out concretely, otherwise it is left out of account.
Third, what is not deducted. The costs of a sale that does not take place — estate agent’s commission, notary, early-repayment penalty — are as a rule left out of account, so long as the value is not itself determined on the basis of an actual sale. Nor is a backlog of maintenance deducted as a flat-rate item of its own; it belongs within the market valuation itself, that is, in the expert report, not in a side calculation after it.
A house from pre-marital ownership, inheritance or gift: the method of calculation
If the house already belonged to one spouse at the time of the marriage, it counts as part of the initial assets at its value on that day (§ 1374 Abs. 1, § 1376 Abs. 1 BGB). If it was acquired during the marriage by inheritance or gift, it is added to the initial assets at its value at the time of acquisition (§ 1374 Abs. 2, § 1376 Abs. 1 BGB). What is equalised is only the accrued gain, that is, the excess of the final assets over the initial assets (§ 1373 BGB).
So that mere currency depreciation does not appear as a gain, the initial assets are converted to the purchasing power of the valuation date. The method:
- Determine the nominal value of the house at the time of acquisition, less the debts charged on it at that time.
- Multiply that figure by the consumer price index for the valuation date and divide by the index for the time of acquisition.
- Determine the market value on the valuation date, less the debt outstanding on the valuation date.
- Take the difference — only that is the accrued gain.
With illustrative figures: a gifted house, worth 200,000 euros at the time of acquisition, free of debt. The index then stood at 80 and at the valuation date at 120. Indexed initial assets: 200,000 × 120 / 80 = 300,000 euros. On the valuation date the house is worth 500,000 euros, with 100,000 euros of the loan outstanding — a final-asset item of 400,000 euros. Accrued gain from the house: 100,000 euros. Not 500,000, not 400,000, not 300,000.
The rebuttal of a presumption matters here: if no inventory of the initial assets was drawn up, it is presumed that the final assets represent the accrued gain (§ 1377 Abs. 3 BGB). Anyone relying on a house from pre-marital ownership must therefore prove its value at the time — purchase contract, certificate of inheritance, deed of gift, a valuation carried out retrospectively.
How the value enters the proceedings
You do not have to guess the value. § 1379 Abs. 1 BGB gives you a right to disclosure of the assets relevant to the initial and final assets, to the production of supporting documents on request, and to having the value of the assets and liabilities determined. Under § 1377 Abs. 2 BGB each spouse may, in addition, obtain an expert’s report at their own expense.
I work in this order: first request disclosure and documents, with a deadline. Then the valuation — ideally a jointly instructed expert, because experience shows that two partisan reports only widen the range. Then draw up the calculation and argue through the deductions. Only after that does the negotiation begin.
Two deadlines frame the whole thing. If you want the equalisation of accrued gains decided within the divorce proceedings, the matrimonial-property matter must be made pending no later than two weeks before the oral hearing at first instance in the divorce case (§ 137 Abs. 2 FamFG). After that, only separate proceedings remain. And the equalisation claim arises on the ending of the property regime (§ 1378 Abs. 3 BGB) and is subject to the ordinary limitation period; this begins at the end of the year in which the claim arose and you knew, or without gross negligence ought to have known, of the relevant circumstances (§ 199 Abs. 1 BGB).
Two limits are worth knowing. The equalisation claim is capped at the value of the assets in existence at the end of the property regime (§ 1378 Abs. 2 BGB) — a house makes you rich on paper, not in the bank. And instead of money the court may, on application, order the transfer of individual assets, where this is necessary to avoid gross inequity and can reasonably be expected of the debtor (§ 1383 BGB). If no agreement at all can be reached about a jointly owned house, the partition sale by auction under § 180 ZVG remains — with the possibility, under the conditions set out there, of having the proceedings suspended for a time, for instance in the interest of a child the couple share.
A typical case
The client continues to live in the house with the children; it belongs to both of them in equal shares. The other spouse puts forward an online valuation of 780,000 euros and demands half the difference between that and the loan. On examination it turns out that the valuation was prepared as at today’s date, whereas the valuation date is fourteen months ago. A report drawn up as at the valuation date arrives at 690,000 euros. Both are borrowers, and the balance on the valuation date was 240,000 euros — so for each of them 345,000 euros of house value and 120,000 euros of debt. The house therefore stands at the same figure in both sets of final assets and, taken on its own, does not move the equalisation claim at all; what is really being decided is the other items, and who takes the house on. Because the house was owner-occupied throughout, a deduction for latent tax is ruled out. The outcome of the negotiation: one party takes over the other’s co-ownership share against a balancing payment in instalments, notarised, with the loan refinanced.
Common mistakes
- Calculating with today’s market value instead of the value on the valuation date. In a rising market this gives away six-figure sums.
- Failing to obtain the disclosure as at separation, and so losing the comparative figure for § 1375 Abs. 2 BGB.
- Deducting the whole loan against one’s own assets, even though both spouses are borrowers.
- Not raising the deduction for latent tax at all — it is not factored in of the court’s own motion.
- Having no inventory of the initial assets and no documents for a house acquired before the marriage, with the consequence of the presumption under § 1377 Abs. 3 BGB.
- Mistaking an online valuation estimate for an expert’s report.
- Being bought out of the land register before the tax consequences have been checked — a transfer within the ten-year period can trigger income tax.
- Letting the consolidation deadline under § 137 Abs. 2 FamFG lapse and ending up running two sets of proceedings.
Frequently asked questions
Does the date of separation count, or the date the divorce petition was served?
For the value of the house in the final assets, what counts is the day the divorce petition was served on the other spouse (§ 1384 BGB). The date of separation serves a different function: it is the reference point for the right to disclosure under § 1379 Abs. 2 BGB and for the question of whether assets were disloyally reduced between separation and the valuation date.
The house is worth considerably more now than on the valuation date. Do I have to share that?
No. Changes in value after the valuation date are left out of account; they belong to the owner — for better or for worse. That said, the valuation date itself can be in dispute, for instance where service of the petition is not cleanly documented; in that case it is worth looking into the court file.
Can the outstanding debt wipe out the value of the house entirely?
Yes. Liabilities are deducted even beyond the amount of the assets (§ 1375 Abs. 1 Satz 2 BGB), so the final assets can become negative. But the ceiling in § 1378 Abs. 2 BGB must be borne in mind: no one has to equalise more than the assets in existence at the end of the property regime.
What do I do if the other side will not allow a valuation?
You can demand that the value be determined (§ 1379 Abs. 1 Satz 3 BGB) and, if need be, obtain an expert’s report at your own expense (§ 1377 Abs. 2 BGB). If the other side refuses disclosure and documents, the claim can be enforced through the court; where it is contested, the family court orders the taking of evidence.
Does the divorce become more expensive if I have the accrued gains decided as well?
The value of the matrimonial-property matter does increase the fees, that is true. What that means in your case I will work through at the first meeting under the RVG; often legal-expenses insurance applies too, and I will submit the request for cover for you. Without knowing this, there is no judging whether consolidated proceedings or separate proceedings are the cheaper course.
Your next step
If you want to know which figure applies in your case, I need three things: the date the divorce petition was served, the land-register extract together with the loan balance on that day, and the documents relating to the acquisition of the house. From these I build up the calculation, identify the items on the other side that are open to challenge, and tell you what can realistically be expected — before the first negotiation, not after it. You will find further articles on houses, land and property under Property law.
Get in touch with your situation; I will look at the documents and tell you how I would proceed. Representation is provided nationwide, and the consultation takes place by video or telephone.
This article gives general information and is no substitute for an examination of your individual case.
This article provides general information and is no substitute for legal advice in an individual case. Last updated: 2026-11-19.

Christian Czirnich, Rechtsanwalt (attorney at law), Kirchseeon near Munich
Tell me when the divorce petition arrived and what the house is worth – I will take a look.
I read every message myself and usually reply on the next working day. What you write to me is covered by legal professional privilege from the first word, even if no engagement comes about. The initial assessment is free of charge.
Your message has arrived. I will usually reply on the next working day. If it is urgent: 08091 617 7777