Back to home
Real Estate Law

We agreed on Building Type E — can I still raise construction defects at all?

An 'E' clause in a building contract lowers the standard only where it says so in concrete terms. What still counts as a defect, which time limits are running, and how to keep your money in hand.

Your contract contains a sentence about “Building Type E”, and now that the house is built, you can hear every footstep from the floor above, the screed is cracking and there is no ventilation. The answer to your list is always the same: but that is what was agreed, you wanted the basic standard. Before you accept that, read this piece — and look at the date of your handover (acceptance).

In short

Yes, you can raise defects. “Building Type E” is still not law, merely a contractual arrangement; the ministerial draft from October 2026 is not in force. A defect therefore remains any departure from the agreed condition (section 633(2) BGB) — and a blanket reference to “E” does not agree a condition, only a heading. As a rule, only what is set out individually and by name in the contract has been contracted out; functional suitability, safety and sound workmanship are still owed.

How I help you

What “Building Type E” actually means in your contract

The “E” stands for simple or experimental building (einfaches oder experimentelles Bauen) and is a building-policy idea, not a legal term. The ministerial draft from the Federal Ministry of Justice dated 26 October 2026 seeks to write a statutory baseline standard into the BGB that applies only if the parties agree it, and in text form at that — a blanket reference to Building Type E is expressly not meant to suffice. The consultation period for the federal states and associations closed on 9 November, and the specialist press criticises the lack of accompanying provisions in tenancy law. For your contract this means: this draft is of no help to your builder, and you do not have to be measured against standards that do not yet apply.

The law in force is the building contract law of the BGB. Your work is free of material defects if it has the agreed condition; where there is no agreement, what matters is the use assumed under the contract, the customary use, and the usual condition you may expect (section 633(2) BGB). Departing from a technical standard is permitted — but only in so far as the departure is actually stated in the contract. Whatever is not regulated remains owed.

On top of that come three levers that are easily overlooked:

What remains a defect despite an E arrangement

Work through your list in this order:

  1. Is the departure stated in concrete terms in the contract? What you are looking for is the component, the omitted standard or the agreed value — for instance a named sound-insulation value instead of the higher one. If that is missing, the yardstick of section 633(2) BGB applies to that point, not the heading “E”.
  2. Does the building function for the purpose set out in the contract? A reduced level of fit-out is one thing; a house that is unsuitable for the living use assumed under the contract is a defect — even with an E arrangement.
  3. Does the point touch on safety or public building law? Structural stability, fire protection, the requirements of the state building regulations and of the Buildings Energy Act are as a rule not at the parties’ disposal. Two private parties cannot validly agree something that the building regulations prohibit.
  4. Is it a question of standard at all — or a workmanship error? Cracks in the screed, leaking connections, damp, crookedly fitted windows: that is not a budget option but poor work, and is covered by no E arrangement.

Time limits: the start, the end, and the trap at handover

For buildings, defect claims become time-barred after five years; the period begins with the handover (section 634a(1) no. 2, (2) BGB). For work that does not concern a building, the period is two years (section 634a(1) no. 1 BGB). If the contractor fraudulently concealed a defect, the standard limitation period applies, which does not expire earlier than the five years (section 634a(3) BGB).

Two things decide whether you are still “in time”:

First, the handover. If you accept a defective work even though you know of the defect, you keep the rights to subsequent performance, self-remedy, rescission and reduction of the price only if you reserved them at handover (section 640(3) BGB). The claim for damages remains open to you even without a reservation. This is the most common reason why a visible defect suddenly becomes unenforceable. Be aware, too, that a work is deemed accepted if you let a reasonable acceptance period pass without naming at least one defect — as against consumers only where the contractor pointed out the consequences in text form (section 640(2) BGB).

Second, the running of the period. Raising a defect alone does not stop the limitation clock. Serious negotiations and independent evidence proceedings suspend it; mere assurances that “we’ll see to it” do not do so reliably. When the five years are running short, that is the point at which you should no longer wait and see. If the VOB/B is incorporated into your contract, it provides for a shorter period — and as against consumers, such a shortening in pre-formulated terms will as a rule not withstand review (section 309 no. 8(b)(ff) BGB).

Your rights and how the sums are worked out

If there is a defect, you have the rights under section 634 BGB. In principle the route runs via subsequent performance: you set a reasonable deadline for the defect to be remedied. If it passes without success, you may have the defect remedied yourself and claim reimbursement of the necessary outlay — and you can demand the amount needed for this in advance (section 637(1) and (3) BGB). In practice this is the strongest lever, because you then do not have to lay out your own money.

Alternatively, you reduce the price (section 638 BGB). The calculation works by way of a ratio: the agreed price is reduced in the proportion that the value of the defect-free work bears to the actual value at the time the contract was concluded, by estimate if need be (section 638(3) BGB). A worked example: agreed price €380,000, value without the defect €400,000, actual value €360,000. The sum is 380,000 × 360,000 / 400,000 = €342,000; the reduction is €38,000. If you have already paid more, the excess is to be reimbursed (section 638(4) BGB).

And for as long as money is still outstanding: if you can demand that the defect be remedied, you may refuse a reasonable portion of the price; as a rule this is up to twice the anticipated cost of remedy (section 641(3) BGB). Pay in full beforehand and you negotiate without any security.

A typical case

A couple buy a semi-detached house from the builder. The contract says “executed as Building Type E”; the building specification names no sound-insulation values. After they move in, the impact sound from next door is clearly audible, the screed shows cracks, and there is no ventilation to the internal bathrooms. The builder points to the E arrangement.

Once the points are sorted, little of the defence survives: the sound insulation is not quantified in the contract at all, and the gap in the building specification is resolved against the builder (section 650k(2) BGB). The screed cracks are a workmanship error and have nothing to do with the standard. The missing ventilation is first and foremost a question of public building law and of function. Only one point is delicate: the cracks were visible at handover and the record contains no reservation — here the focus remains on damages (section 640(3) BGB in conjunction with section 634 no. 4 BGB). The approach: a list of defects with a deadline, a demand for an advance payment for the items the builder disputes, withholding of the final payment, and securing the evidence before any remedial work.

Common mistakes

Frequently asked questions

Is the sentence “executed as Building Type E” enough to contract out the recognised rules of technology?

On its own, as a rule no. The yardstick for a defect is the agreed condition (section 633(2) BGB), and a collective label does not say which standard is to apply to which component. With pre-formulated terms there is the added point that surprising clauses do not become part of the contract and ambiguities are resolved against the party using them (section 305c BGB).

Does the Building Type E Act already apply to my contract?

No. As matters stand today there is a ministerial draft dated 26 October 2026, and the consultation period closed on 9 November 2026. A draft is not a law; your contract is governed by the building contract law of the BGB in the version in force.

I said nothing at handover — have I lost my rights?

Not all of them, and it depends on whether you knew of the defect at the time. For known defects without a reservation, subsequent performance, self-remedy, rescission and reduction of the price fall away (section 640(3) BGB); damages remain possible. For defects that were not detectable at the time, this does not apply.

How much may I withhold until the defect is remedied?

A reasonable portion of the price, as a guide usually up to twice the anticipated cost of remedy (section 641(3) BGB). What matters is a robust estimate of those costs — withhold too much and you risk falling into default yourself.

Do I have to prove that there is a defect?

After handover, yes: at that point you bear the burden for both the defect and its cause. That is why photographs, measurements and, if necessary, an expert’s report belong at the start, not at the end — independent evidence proceedings secure the condition and at the same time suspend the limitation period.

Your next step

Put your building contract, building specification, handover record and list of defects together and get in touch before the time limit under section 634a BGB draws nearer or you make the final payment. I will check what the E arrangement really contracts out in your case, raise the defects with a deadline and secure both evidence and payments; what else I handle for building owners in property law you can see there. What the work costs, I will tell you at the first consultation under the RVG, and on request I will clarify cover with your legal expenses insurer. I work nationwide, by video or telephone.

This article provides general information and is no substitute for advice in your individual case.

This article provides general information and is no substitute for legal advice in an individual case. Last updated: 2026-11-21.

Christian Czirnich, Rechtsanwalt (attorney at law), Kirchseeon near Munich

Tell me what your contract says about Building Type E and what is defective – I will look into it.

I read every message myself and usually reply on the next working day. What you write to me is covered by legal professional privilege from the first word, even if no engagement comes about. The initial assessment is free of charge.

Encrypted in transit, stored encrypted, readable only by me. Details in the privacy policy.