Real Estate Law2026-09-21

The service charge statement arrived late – do I still have to pay the shortfall?

If your service charge statement only reaches you after the twelve-month deadline has passed, the landlord can usually no longer claim a shortfall from you. What that means for you – and where the exceptions lie.

The envelope from your landlord or the managing agent is sitting in the letterbox. The statement covers a year that ended long ago – and at the bottom there is a shortfall to pay. Your first thought: isn’t this coming far too late? That is exactly what this article is about – not how the statement is put together, and not what may be passed on to you as a cost. It is solely about what a late statement means for your obligation to pay.

In short

If the statement only reaches you more than twelve months after the end of the accounting period, the landlord can no longer demand any further payment from you. The additional claim is then barred. This deadline, however, only protects you as the tenant: if the late statement shows a credit balance in your favour, it still has to be paid out to you. There is one important exception, though: if the landlord is not responsible for the delay, the claim survives.

How I can help you

I check whether the twelve-month deadline has already expired in your particular case.
I establish whether the statement was even formally complete, and therefore capable of meeting the deadline when it was received.
I assess whether the landlord is rightly relying on an exception (“not responsible for the delay”).
I reject unjustified claims against the landlord or the managing agent on your behalf.
I enforce any credit balance that stands despite the delay.

The twelve-month deadline: start, end and receipt

Under § 556 Abs. 3 BGB, the landlord must account annually for the advance payments made towards operating costs. The deadline for doing so begins at the end of the accounting period – usually the calendar year – and runs for twelve months. For the 2025 accounting period (1 January to 31 December 2025), the deadline therefore ends on 31 December 2026. That is precisely why so many letterboxes fill up again this autumn: landlords who have not yet accounted are trying to meet the deadline in time.

What matters here is not the date printed on the statement, but when it actually reaches you. The statement must arrive with you while the deadline is still running. It must have entered your sphere of control in such a way that, in the ordinary course of events, you were able to take note of it. A letter dated 30 December that only lands in the letterbox on 3 January does not meet the deadline. It is the landlord who bears the burden of proving timely receipt, not you.

What expiry of the deadline achieves in law – and what it does not

The bar under § 556 Abs. 3 BGB operates in one direction only. Once the deadline has passed, the landlord loses the right to pursue a further claim against you. It does not, however, release you from accepting a credit balance arising from the same – late – statement. If a landlord wrongly sets off a credit balance against a claim that is already barred, you do not have to accept this.

Just as importantly: expiry of the deadline does not release the landlord from the duty to produce a statement at all. If the landlord fails to account entirely, you can still demand that a statement be drawn up. But once the deadline has passed, this no longer gives rise to any obligation on your part to make a further payment.

The exception: a delay the landlord “is not responsible for”

The landlord can still rely on a claim despite expiry of the deadline where he is not responsible for the delay. This is a narrow exception. The landlord must set out and prove that the delay lay outside his sphere of influence. That is the case, for example, where a utility company has itself accounted late despite a timely request. The landlord’s own organisational shortcomings, understaffing at the managing agent, or simply being pressed for time are not enough. If a late claim is justified to you on this basis, it is worth looking at it closely. Was the delay genuinely unavoidable, or could the landlord have prevented it with greater care?

Formally incomplete statements: do they meet the deadline or not?

Not every document headed “service charge statement” meets the statutory requirements. Those requirements follow from § 556 Abs. 3 BGB. So that you, as the tenant, can follow the statement and check the arithmetic, it must at its core contain: a summary of the total costs for each type of cost, the apportionment key applied together with an explanation of how it was applied to your flat, the resulting cost item allocated to you, and the deduction of the advance payments you have made. If one of these details is missing entirely, the statement is formally incomplete.

This can have a direct effect on the deadline. Where these minimum details are missing, the statement may not meet the deadline at all. The twelve-month period then continues to run until a complete statement is provided. Mere arithmetical errors or incorrect individual figures, by contrast, are substantive defects. They do not call into question the fact that a deadline-meeting statement was received. The landlord can generally still correct such defects even after the deadline has passed – but only in your favour, and not so as to revive a claim that is already barred.

A typical case from practice

A tenant receives, in March, the statement for a year that ended in December two years earlier. The twelve-month deadline has therefore long since passed. The statement shows a shortfall of several hundred euros. When asked, the managing agent points to a change of billing service provider as the reason for the delay. That is not enough by way of excuse. An internal change of service provider falls within the landlord’s area of organisation. The claim is barred. The tenant does not have to pay. She could, however, still have claimed a partial credit balance arising from the very same statement – it stemmed from advance payments for heating costs that had been set too high.

Common mistakes

Paying the shortfall without checking, simply because an invoice with a payment date has arrived
Confusing the start of the deadline with the date on the statement instead of the end of the accounting period
Overlooking the fact that a formally incomplete statement may not meet the deadline in the first place
Failing to claim a credit balance that is due – often on the mistaken assumption that, once the deadline has passed, “everything is settled”
Not documenting when the statement was received, even though this is precisely what proves decisive in a dispute

Frequently asked questions

When exactly does the twelve-month deadline start to run?

It begins at the end of the accounting period – as a rule, therefore, on 31 December of the year in question. It ends twelve months later. For the 2025 accounting period this means: the statement must have reached you by 31 December 2026 at the latest.

Do I have to reject a late claim expressly?

Yes. The bar does take effect automatically, by operation of law, but landlords nonetheless regularly pursue late shortfalls all the same. Do not simply pay without comment; reject the claim in writing, pointing to the fact that the deadline has expired.

What if I have already paid the late statement?

If you paid where there was no legal basis to do so, you can in principle reclaim the amount. How long that remains possible, and what evidence you need for it, depends on the individual case. It is best that I look into this for you promptly.

Does the twelve-month deadline also apply if I have moved out?

Yes. The deadline is tied to the accounting period, not to an ongoing tenancy. A statement must still be provided to you on time after you have moved out, and the bar on late claims applies then too.

What if the statement is substantively wrong but arrived on time?

That is a different problem from lateness: here it is about your own right to object to the statement. A separate twelve-month deadline applies to that, running from the receipt of the statement. You must raise your objections within that period.

Your next step

If a service charge statement showing a shortfall has just arrived, it is worth a quick check of the deadline before you pay anything. Ask yourself: when did the accounting period end? When exactly did the statement reach you? Does it even contain all the necessary details? I check this for you and, where needed, draft the rejection to the landlord or managing agent. I also clarify whether, on top of that, a credit balance is due to you. Do get in touch – particularly now, in the autumn, when many statements for 2025 are landing and the barring deadline for older years is visibly running out. You will find more on this and related topics under real estate law.

The next part of this series deals with formal errors that render a service charge statement invalid as a whole – regardless of whether it was received on time.

This article provides general information and does not replace individual legal advice. Every case turns on its own particular circumstances. If in doubt, seek advice tailored to your specific situation.

This article provides general information and is no substitute for legal advice in an individual case. Last updated: 2026-09-21.

Request an initial consultation What will it cost me?08091 617 7777