Back to home
Employment Law

I've been placed at the same company for over 18 months – am I now employed there?

If the maximum hire-out period is exceeded, an employment relationship with the hirer can arise by operation of law. What you need to work out, which one-month deadline is running, and how to enforce the claim.

You have been working as an agency worker at the same company for more than 18 months, doing the same work as the permanent staff – and you are wondering whether you have by now become their employee. It is a fair question, because the law does draw a line. Whether that line has been crossed in your case, however, turns on details that you need to work out and prove.

In short

The mere fact that 18 months have elapsed does not automatically make you an employee of the company you are placed with. But if the maximum hire-out period that applies to you has in fact been exceeded, your employment contract with the temporary work agency (the “lender”) becomes invalid (§ 9 Abs. 1 Nr. 1b AÜG), and an employment relationship with the hirer is deemed to have come into existence (§ 10 Abs. 1 AÜG). This happens by operation of law – unless you submit a valid “declaration of adherence” (Festhaltenserklärung) within one month. Because lenders and hirers rarely acknowledge this voluntarily in practice, the point is usually settled by bringing a declaratory action before the labour court.

How I can help

When the 18 months have genuinely been exceeded

The limit is tied to the person, not to the job: the same agency worker may not be hired out to the same hirer for more than 18 consecutive months, and the hirer may not have them work for any longer (§ 1 Abs. 1b AÜG). So the fact that other agency workers sat in your role before you is irrelevant to your own deadline – whereas the fact that you yourself were there at an earlier point very much counts.

Here is how I calculate it:

  1. List every placement with this hirer, with start and end dates – including those that ran through a different agency.
  2. Identify the gaps between placements. If no more than three months lie between two placements, the earlier period is counted in full. A break of more than three months resets the clock.
  3. Add up the blocks linked in this way and compare the total with the maximum duration that applies to you.

An important point in practice: a change of agency resets nothing, as long as the hirer stays the same. Conversely, a placement with a different hirer does not count towards it, not even within the same group of companies. Holiday, sickness or short-time working do not usually bring the ongoing placement to an end – if you remain hired out to the hirer during that time, the clock keeps running. Whether periods of placement continue to count when the hirer’s business is transferred to a different legal entity is not expressly governed by the legislation; the question is currently occupying the labour courts, and a reform of the use of external personnel is also under political discussion. In such situations, careful examination is especially worthwhile.

Where a collective agreement applies, 18 months can be more

The 18 months are the statutory default, not an absolute ceiling. The parties to a collective agreement in the hirer’s sector – and it is the hirer’s sector that matters, not the agency’s – can set a different maximum duration. Within the scope of such a collective agreement, a hirer that is not itself bound by it can adopt the collectively agreed rule through a works or service agreement; where the collective agreement provides for this and lays down nothing to the contrary, up to 24 months are possible. Churches and religious bodies constituted under public law have their own options for regulating this.

That is why I always examine three questions: Which collective agreement applies to the hirer’s sector? Is there a works agreement on the hire-out period at the company you are placed with – and since when? Does it actually cover your period of placement? An extension that was only adopted after your 18 months had already run out does the hirer no good for the past.

What happens when the limit falls – and the trap of the one-month deadline

When the maximum duration is exceeded, your employment contract with the agency becomes invalid. In its place comes an employment relationship with the hirer, deemed to have come into existence from the moment that invalidity takes effect. The content and duration are governed by the rules and provisions applicable at the hirer’s business, your working hours follow what the lender and hirer had agreed, and you are entitled, as against the hirer, to at least the pay you had agreed with the agency. In practice this often means more: where a collective agreement applies at the company you are placed with, your remuneration may be considerably higher than your previous agency pay.

You can, however, undo this effect yourself – and this is precisely where it becomes dangerous. By submitting a declaration of adherence (Festhaltenserklärung), you declare that you wish to stick with your contract with the agency. It only takes effect under strict conditions (§ 9 Abs. 2, 3 AÜG):

The flip side is this: do nothing, and you lose nothing. You need not submit any declaration for the employment relationship with the hirer to arise. The declaration is the way back to the agency – not the way into the company you are placed with.

How I proceed

First we secure the evidence: employment contract, hire-out notices, payslips showing the place of assignment, duty and shift rotas, time records, works pass, emails, access and training records. Then I request information from the hirer about the essential working conditions of comparable permanent staff, including pay (§ 13 AÜG) – we need this in order to quantify your claim. After that, I call on the hirer to employ you and expressly offer your services.

If the hirer refuses, I bring a declaratory action before the labour court, seeking a declaration that an employment relationship has existed between you and the hirer since a particular date; the legal interest in such a declaration follows from § 256 Abs. 1 ZPO. The court with jurisdiction is the labour court in whose district the hirer has its seat, or in which you habitually worked – not necessarily the court at the agency’s seat. There is no rigid three-week deadline for this action as there is for a dismissal. Waiting is risky all the same: evidence disappears, witnesses change employers, and the longer you live with the existing state of affairs without objection, the readier the other side will be to hold that against you. If the lender or the hirer does give you notice of dismissal, then the three-week deadline most certainly does apply to the action challenging that dismissal.

The fact that exceeding the maximum duration can also be penalised as a regulatory offence, with a fine of up to 30,000 euros, and that the Bundesagentur für Arbeit is responsible for this, increases the pressure on the other side – but it does not substitute for your claim to be employed.

A typical case

A production worker is placed at a company through a temporary work agency for 14 months. The placement then ends; ten weeks later it begins again – this time through a different agency, on the same line, with the same supervisor. After a further six months, the new agency puts a form in front of him “for the continuation of the placement” and asks him to sign it. In reality the break was under three months, the 14 months count in full, and the maximum duration has been exceeded for weeks. The change of agency makes no difference to that. The form is a declaration of adherence – if he signs it and it is properly presented and served, he gives up the employment relationship with the company he is placed with. If he does not sign, the case is about the declaration that he is employed there, and about the pay differential.

Common mistakes

Once you have decided not to accept this, the next step is the route to the labour court – how such an action unfolds, what it costs you and what is negotiated in the process is explained on the page about bringing a claim before the labour court.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to bring my claim within three weeks?

No three-week deadline applies to establishing that an employment relationship with the hirer exists. The short deadline you may know from dismissal protection only bites once someone gives you notice – you then have three weeks from receipt to bring an unfair dismissal claim. Even so, you should not wait unnecessarily before bringing the declaratory action, because both your evidence and your negotiating position deteriorate over time.

Does a sick note or my holiday count as an interruption?

As a rule, no. The deadline attaches to the hiring out, not to the days on which you are actually on the line or at your desk. If you remain hired out to the same hirer during your sickness or holiday, the maximum duration keeps running. The position may be different if the hire-out is actually brought to an end during that time and later freshly established – then it comes down to the length of the gap.

What will I earn if an employment relationship with the hirer exists?

At least the pay you had agreed with the agency. Beyond that, the content and duration of the employment relationship are governed by the rules and provisions applicable at the company you are placed with; where none exist there, by those of comparable businesses. Where a collective agreement applies at the company, it can give rise to a substantial back-payment for the period after the maximum duration was exceeded.

Can the company dismiss me again straight away?

It can give notice, but not as it pleases. The deemed employment relationship is subject to the same rules as any other: notice periods, a ground for dismissal where dismissal protection applies, involvement of the works council. What matters is that your time on placement may count towards the qualifying period and towards length of service – and that calls for a case-by-case assessment.

I have already signed a declaration of adherence – is everything lost?

Not necessarily. The declaration only takes effect if all the formalities have been observed: written form, presentation in person at an Agentur für Arbeit before signing, with a date and confirmation of identity, receipt by the lender or hirer no later than the third day afterwards, and not before the one-month period begins. If any one of these is missing, the declaration comes to nothing. In addition, the invalidity rules remain applicable if the placement is continued afterwards – and a repeat declaration of adherence is invalid.

Your next step

What you need now is a sound calculation: which placements count together, on which day the maximum duration was exceeded, and whether the one-month period is still running. To that end, gather your placement and pay records, sign nothing that the lender or hirer puts in front of you until matters are clarified, and have the periods examined. I will look at your documents, tell you whether an employment relationship with the company you are placed with has arisen, and take on the enforcement – from the initial demand through to the court action. For an overview of the other topics in this area, see employment law. The cost of an initial consultation and of any further work under the RVG I discuss openly with you beforehand; I will make enquiries with your legal expenses insurer on your behalf. Advice is available nationwide, by video or telephone.

This article provides general information and is no substitute for an examination of your individual case.

This article provides general information and is no substitute for legal advice in an individual case. Last updated: 2026-11-18.

Christian Czirnich, Rechtsanwalt (attorney at law), Kirchseeon near Munich

Tell me when your placement at the company started – I will look into it.

I read every message myself and usually reply on the next working day. What you write to me is covered by legal professional privilege from the first word, even if no engagement comes about. The initial assessment is free of charge.

Encrypted in transit, stored encrypted, readable only by me. Details in the privacy policy.